Cookout Milkshake Menu — All Flavors, Prices & Sizes (2026)
The Cookout milkshake menu is one of the biggest reasons people keep coming back to this Southeastern fast-food chain. With over 40 milkshake flavors available, Cookout offers more shake variety than almost any other fast-food restaurant in the United States.
Most national chains like McDonald’s or Chick-fil-A offer 4 to 6 milkshake options at most. Cookout offers 40+. That is not a small difference — it is a completely different experience for anyone who takes their shakes seriously.
Search data backs this up. The keyword “cookout milkshakes” gets over 7,300 monthly searches in the US, and “cookout milkshake flavors” gets another 4,600. Clearly, people want to know exactly what is on the shake menu before they order.
This guide covers every flavor, current prices, size options, fan favorites, and answers to the most common questions about Cookout shakes.
Cookout Milkshake Overview
Cookout shakes are hand-spun milkshakes made with real ice cream. They are thick, creamy, and come in a size range that fits both casual cravings and serious appetites. Whether you order a large Cookout milkshake on its own or add a small shake as one of your two Cookout Tray sides, the quality stays consistent.
Here is a quick look at what sets Cookout shakes apart from other fast-food options:
- Flavor count: 40+ flavors, including classic, specialty, and seasonal options
- Base: Real ice cream — not soft-serve mix
- Tray option: A small shake counts as one of your two Tray sides at no extra charge
- Price: Large shakes typically cost $2.99 to $3.99 — lower than most fast-food competitors
- Availability: Available at all Cookout locations across 10 Southeastern states
Cookout Milkshake Sizes and Prices
Cookout milkshakes come in two size options — small and large. The small size is designed to pair with the Cookout Tray as a side item. The large size is a standalone order for shake lovers who want a full serving.
| Size | How to Order | Approx. Price |
| Small Shake | As a Tray side (included in Tray price) | Included in Tray ($5.49–$6.99) |
| Large Shake | Standalone order | $2.99 – $3.99 |
Prices can vary slightly by location. The official Cookout website does not list prices publicly, so figures here are based on the most commonly reported 2026 prices from customers across US locations.
All Cookout Milkshake Flavors — Complete List
Below is the most complete list of Cookout milkshake flavors available as of 2026. Flavors are grouped by category to make it easier to find what you are looking for. Not every location carries every flavor — regional specialties like Cheerwine may only be available in certain states.
Classic Milkshake Flavors
These are the core flavors you will find at every Cookout location. They are the most ordered and the safest choice if you are visiting for the first time.
| Flavor | Taste Profile |
| Chocolate | Rich, deep cocoa flavor |
| Vanilla | Smooth, creamy classic |
| Strawberry | Sweet with real strawberry taste |
| Banana | Ripe banana, naturally sweet |
| Peach | Light and fruity, Southern-style |
| Cherry | Bold cherry flavor, slightly tart |
| Blueberry | Sweet with a mild berry finish |
| Lemon | Bright and tangy, refreshing |
| Orange | Citrus-forward, creamy base |
| Pineapple | Tropical and sweet |
Candy and Dessert Flavors
These Cookout shake flavors are built around popular candy bars and dessert ingredients. They tend to be richer and sweeter than the classic options. These are a big hit with younger customers and anyone with a serious sweet tooth.
| Flavor | Base Ingredient |
| Oreo | Crushed Oreo cookies blended in |
| Oreo Mint | Oreo + cool mint flavor |
| Butterfinger | Crunchy peanut butter candy |
| Reese’s Cup | Peanut butter + chocolate |
| Snickers | Chocolate, caramel, and peanut |
| M&M | Milk chocolate candy blend |
| Kit Kat | Crispy wafer chocolate blend |
| Caramel | Rich, buttery caramel swirl |
| Cheesecake | Creamy cheesecake base |
| Banana Pudding | Vanilla wafer and banana cream |
Specialty and Regional Flavors
This is where Cookout’s milkshake menu really stands out. These specialty flavors are either region-specific or seasonal. If you live in North Carolina, South Carolina, or Virginia, you are most likely to find the full range of these options at your local Cookout.
| Flavor | What Makes It Special |
| Cheerwine | Made with Cheerwine — a NC-based cherry soda brand. A regional icon. |
| Peanut Butter | Pure peanut butter blended with vanilla ice cream |
| Peanut Butter Fudge | Peanut butter with a fudge swirl |
| Watermelon | Sweet summer flavor, seasonal availability |
| Coconut | Tropical and creamy, lighter sweetness |
| Mint Chocolate Chip | Cool mint with chocolate chip pieces |
| Coffee | Bold espresso flavor for coffee lovers |
| Mocha | Coffee and chocolate combined |
| Pumpkin | Seasonal — fall availability at select locations |
| Red Velvet | Cream cheese and cocoa flavor |
The Cheerwine milkshake deserves special mention. Cheerwine is a cherry-flavored carbonated drink that has been produced in Salisbury, North Carolina since 1917. According to the Cheerwine brand website, it is one of the oldest surviving regional soft drinks in the United States. Cookout’s Cheerwine shake blends this iconic soda into their vanilla ice cream base — the result is a uniquely Southern flavor that you simply cannot find anywhere else.
Best Cookout Milkshake Flavors — Fan Favorites
Not all 40+ flavors are equal in popularity. Based on customer reviews, Reddit threads, and food blog discussions, these are the top-rated Cookout milkshake flavors that fans order again and again.
- Banana Pudding — Consistently rated as the number one fan favorite. The combination of vanilla wafers, banana cream, and Cookout’s ice cream base creates a thick, dessert-like shake that feels like a full meal on its own.
- Cheerwine — The regional specialty that outsiders drive out of their way to try. If you are in a state where Cheerwine is sold, this shake is a must-order at least once.
- Peanut Butter — Simple but powerful. Real peanut butter blended into vanilla ice cream creates one of the thickest, most filling shakes on the menu.
- Oreo Mint — A step up from plain Oreo. The mint adds a cool freshness that balances the sweetness of the cookie blend.
- Reese’s Cup — A chocolate and peanut butter combination that hits every note for fans of the classic candy pairing.
- Strawberry — The best classic option for those who prefer fruit-forward flavors over candy-heavy ones. Light, sweet, and refreshing.
Peanut Butter Milkshake at Cookout — What to Expect
The peanut butter milkshake at Cookout is one of the most searched individual shake flavors, with over 2,200 monthly searches for related terms. It is easy to see why — peanut butter shakes are polarizing. Some people love them, others have had bad versions elsewhere.
At Cookout, the peanut butter shake uses real peanut butter — not a flavored syrup or powder. That makes it one of the thickest shakes on the menu. It is dense, rich, and best enjoyed with a spoon rather than a straw if you like it extra thick.
If you want to make it even more indulgent, ask about combining flavors — many Cookout locations allow you to mix two flavors in one shake. Peanut butter + chocolate and peanut butter + banana are two popular combinations.
How to Order a Cookout Milkshake
Ordering a shake at Cookout is simple, but there are a few things worth knowing before you get to the window — especially since the menu is large and the drive-through line can move fast.
Ordering a Large Shake Standalone
- Pull up to the drive-through or walk-in counter (most Cookout locations are drive-through only)
- Ask for a large milkshake and state your flavor
- If your location allows flavor mixing, request your combination at this point
- Pay separately — large shakes are priced at approximately $2.99 to $3.99
Adding a Shake to Your Cookout Tray
- Order your Cookout Tray and choose your main item
- When asked for your two sides, say “small shake” as one of your sides
- State the shake flavor you want
- The small shake is included in the Tray price — no extra charge
Pro tip: If you are not sure which flavor to pick, tell the staff it is your first time and ask what is most popular at that location. Most Cookout employees are happy to give a quick recommendation.
Cookout Milkshake vs. Competitors — How Does It Compare?
How does the Cookout shake experience stack up against other fast-food chains? Here is a straightforward comparison based on flavor count, pricing, and shake quality.
| Restaurant | Shake Flavors | Large Shake Price (Approx.) | Real Ice Cream? |
| Cookout | 40+ | $2.99 – $3.99 | Yes |
| McDonald’s | 3–4 | $4.49 – $5.29 | No (mix-based) |
| Chick-fil-A | 4–5 | $4.25 – $4.99 | Yes (Icedream) |
| Sonic | 5–6 + mix-ins | $4.39 – $5.29 | Yes |
| Steak ‘n Shake | 20+ | $3.99 – $4.99 | Yes |
| Five Guys | 10+ | $6.99 – $8.49 | Yes |
Cookout wins on flavor variety and price by a clear margin. Even Steak ‘n Shake, which is known for its milkshake menu, offers fewer than half the flavors Cookout does. And Five Guys — while excellent — charges nearly double the price for a comparable shake.
Cookout Shake Menu — Seasonal and Limited Flavors
Not every Cookout milkshake flavor is available year-round. Some flavors are tied to seasons or regional availability. Here is what you can generally expect:
- Fall/Autumn: Pumpkin shake appears at select locations from September through November
- Summer: Watermelon shake is typically available during peak summer months (June–August)
- Year-round at most locations: All classic flavors plus Oreo, Banana Pudding, Cheerwine, Peanut Butter, and Reese’s Cup
- Regional only: Cheerwine shake is primarily available in North Carolina, South Carolina, and Virginia
Because Cookout does not publish a seasonal schedule publicly, the best way to confirm availability is to call your local location before visiting — especially if you are planning a trip specifically for a limited flavor.
Frequently Asked Questions — Cookout Milkshakes
How many milkshake flavors does Cookout have?
Cookout offers over 40 milkshake flavors. The exact count can vary by location and season, but the standard menu consistently includes more than 40 options. This makes Cookout one of the most shake-diverse fast-food chains in the United States.
Can you mix two milkshake flavors at Cookout?
Yes, at most Cookout locations you can combine two flavors in one shake. Popular combinations include chocolate and peanut butter, banana and strawberry, and Oreo and vanilla. Ask your local location if this option is available, as it may vary.
Is the Cookout milkshake made with real ice cream?
Yes. Cookout milkshakes are made with real ice cream, not soft-serve mix or a pre-made liquid shake base. This is one of the main reasons Cookout shakes are thicker and richer than what you get at many other fast-food chains.
How much does a Cookout milkshake cost?
A large Cookout milkshake costs approximately $2.99 to $3.99 depending on your location and flavor choice. A small shake is included at no extra cost when you order it as one of your two Cookout Tray sides.
Does Cookout have a seasonal milkshake menu?
Yes, some flavors are seasonal. The pumpkin shake typically appears in fall, and the watermelon shake is usually a summer option. Not all locations participate in seasonal offerings. Call ahead to confirm what is currently available.
What is the most popular Cookout milkshake flavor?
Based on customer feedback across food review platforms and social media, Banana Pudding is consistently ranked as the top fan favorite. The Cheerwine and Peanut Butter shakes are close behind, particularly among regular Cookout customers.
Can you get a milkshake without visiting the drive-through?
Most Cookout locations are drive-through only and do not have an indoor dining area. Some locations do have a walk-up window. Cookout shakes are also available through delivery services like DoorDash and Uber Eats at select locations, though availability varies by area.
Tips for Getting the Most Out of the Cookout Shake Menu
If you are visiting Cookout primarily for the milkshakes, here are a few things that make the experience better:
- Order your shake last in the Tray sequence. When placing a Tray order, choose your shake flavor after your main item and first side. This gives you a moment to think rather than deciding under pressure at the drive-through speaker.
- Ask about flavor mixing. Not all locations advertise this, but many allow two-flavor combinations. Just ask when ordering.
- Try the Cheerwine shake if you are in NC or VA. It is a regional experience that does not translate anywhere else. Even if cherry-flavored drinks are not your usual preference, the combination with vanilla ice cream is different from what you might expect.
- Go large if it is a standalone order. At $2.99 to $3.99, the large Cookout shake is genuinely one of the best value milkshakes at any fast-food chain in 2026.
- Pair with a Tray for maximum value. Adding a small shake as a Tray side is the best deal on the menu — you get a shake, two other items, and a drink for under $7 total.
Final Thoughts
The Cookout milkshake menu is not just a list of shake flavors — it is one of the defining features of what makes Cookout different from every other fast-food chain in the Southeast. With 40+ flavors, real ice cream, prices under $4, and the option to include a shake as a Tray side, there is genuinely nothing else like it in fast food.
Whether you are a first-timer deciding between Banana Pudding and Cheerwine, or a regular looking for a new flavor to try, the shake menu at Cookout rewards exploration. The best approach is simple: pick one flavor you know you will enjoy, and then try something you have never had before as your second choice.
For the most up-to-date flavor availability and to find your nearest location, visit the official Cookout website. Flavors and availability may vary by location.
Note: Prices and flavor availability listed in this article are approximate and based on commonly reported 2026 figures from Cookout customers across the US. Actual prices and menu options may vary by location. Always confirm with your local Cookout restaurant.
